9 Best Restaurants in Safety Harbor, Florida: A Food Lover’s Guide
Safety Harbor, Florida, is not only known for its charming streets and beautiful bay views but also for its vibrant culinary scene. Whether you’re a seafood aficionado, an enthusiast of American cuisine, or simply someone who loves good food, Safety Harbor has something to tantalize your taste buds. Here’s a guide to the best restaurants in Safety Harbor, FL, showcasing the top places to eat, from casual eateries to fine dining establishments.
Winner: Southern Fresh
Parts of Paris Bistro & Bar
Bar Fly Saltwater Grill
The Sandwich on Main
Whistle Stop Grill & Bar
Pizzeria Gregario
Athens Restaurant
Nolan's Pub
The Kitchen & Bar at Safety Harbor Resort
1. Southern Fresh
Southern Fresh - 122 3rd Ave N, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
Southern Fresh is a beloved spot in Safety Harbor known for its comforting Southern cuisine and welcoming atmosphere. This restaurant offers a cozy dining experience with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, making it one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
Southern Fresh provides a warm, homely atmosphere where diners can enjoy hearty Southern dishes made from scratch. The friendly service and delicious food make it a local favorite among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The fried chicken is a standout dish, crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside, served with a side of creamy mashed potatoes. The shrimp and grits are another favorite, with perfectly cooked shrimp in a savory sauce. For dessert, try the homemade peach cobbler, a sweet and satisfying end to your meal. Their cornbread, served warm with honey butter, is a delightful starter, ensuring Southern Fresh remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
2. Parts of Paris Bistro & Bar
Parts of Paris Bistro & Bar - 146 4th Ave N, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
Parts of Paris Bistro & Bar offers a charming and intimate dining experience with a menu inspired by French cuisine. The restaurant is set in a beautifully restored historic house, adding to its unique ambiance and making it one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
The French-inspired menu and cozy setting make Parts of Paris a perfect spot for a romantic dinner or special occasion. The elegant decor and attentive service enhance the dining experience, placing it among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The escargot, prepared with garlic and herbs, is a delicious and traditional French starter. The duck confit, tender and flavorful, is a must-try main course. For dessert, the crème brûlée is a classic choice, with a creamy custard and caramelized sugar top. Their French onion soup, rich and savory, is perfect for starting your meal and solidifies Parts of Paris as one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
3. Bar Fly Saltwater Grill
Bar Fly Saltwater Grill - 100 Main St, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
Bar Fly Saltwater Grill offers a laid-back atmosphere with a menu focused on fresh seafood and tropical drinks. Located near the water, it’s an ideal spot for a relaxed meal with friends and is considered one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
The beachy vibe and fresh seafood dishes make Bar Fly a popular choice for both locals and visitors. The outdoor seating area provides beautiful views, adding to the overall experience and making it one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The fish tacos, filled with fresh, flaky fish and topped with a tangy slaw, are a favorite. The shrimp po' boy, served on a soft roll with crispy shrimp, is another must-try. For dessert, try the key lime pie, a refreshing and tart treat. Their tropical cocktails, like the signature Bar Fly Punch, are perfect for pairing with your meal, ensuring Bar Fly remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
4. The Sandwich on Main
The Sandwich on Main - 308 Main St, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
The Sandwich on Main is a cozy spot offering a variety of gourmet sandwiches, salads, and soups. The casual atmosphere and friendly service make it a great place for a quick and delicious meal, earning it a spot among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
The Sandwich on Main focuses on high-quality ingredients and creative combinations, making each sandwich a unique culinary experience. The relaxed setting is perfect for a casual lunch or dinner, solidifying its place as one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The Italian sub, packed with cured meats, cheese, and fresh veggies, is a standout choice. The turkey avocado sandwich, with its creamy avocado and savory turkey, is a customer favorite. For dessert, try one of their freshly baked cookies. The homemade soup of the day is always a great addition to your meal, ensuring The Sandwich on Main remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
5. Whistle Stop Grill & Bar
Whistle Stop Grill & Bar - 915 Main St, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
Whistle Stop Grill & Bar is a family-friendly restaurant known for its classic American fare and vibrant outdoor seating area. The lively atmosphere and extensive menu make it a great spot for any occasion, making it one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
The Whistle Stop offers a fun, casual dining experience with a menu that has something for everyone. The large outdoor seating area is perfect for enjoying Florida’s beautiful weather, earning it a place among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The Whistle Stop Burger, juicy and flavorful, is a must-try. The fried green tomatoes, crispy and tangy, are a popular appetizer. For dessert, the brownie sundae is a decadent treat. Their wings, available in a variety of sauces, are perfect for sharing with friends, ensuring Whistle Stop Grill & Bar remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
6. Pizzeria Gregario
Pizzeria Gregario - 400 2nd St N, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
Pizzeria Gregario is a local favorite for wood-fired pizzas made with fresh, organic ingredients. The cozy atmosphere and delicious pizzas make it a great spot for a casual meal, earning it a spot among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
Pizzeria Gregario’s commitment to using high-quality, organic ingredients sets it apart from other pizzerias. The wood-fired oven gives each pizza a perfect, crispy crust, solidifying its place as one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The Margherita pizza, with fresh tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella, is a classic choice. The truffle mushroom pizza, topped with mushrooms and truffle oil, is a customer favorite. For dessert, try the Nutella pizza, a sweet and indulgent treat. Their house-made garlic knots, served with marinara sauce, are a perfect starter, ensuring Pizzeria Gregario remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
7. Athens Restaurant
Athens Restaurant - 226 Main St, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
Athens Restaurant brings the flavors of Greece to Safety Harbor with its menu of traditional Greek dishes. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it a great place for a family meal, earning it a spot among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
Athens Restaurant’s authentic Greek cuisine and friendly service make it a standout in Safety Harbor. The beautiful decor and relaxed ambiance enhance the dining experience, solidifying its place as one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The moussaka, with its layers of eggplant, ground meat, and béchamel sauce, is a classic Greek dish. The gyro platter, with tender, seasoned meat and fresh pita, is a favorite among diners. For dessert, the baklava, with its layers of phyllo dough, nuts, and honey, is a must-try. The spanakopita, filled with spinach and feta, is a delicious appetizer, ensuring Athens Restaurant remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
8. Nolan's Pub
Nolan's Pub - 230 Main St, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
Nolan's Pub is a cozy Irish pub offering a variety of beers on tap and a menu filled with pub favorites. The friendly atmosphere and live music make it a popular spot for a night out, earning it a spot among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
Nolan's Pub’s lively atmosphere and great selection of beers make it a favorite among locals. The welcoming vibe and regular live music performances add to the charm, solidifying its place as one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The fish and chips, with its crispy batter and tender fish, is a classic pub dish done right. The shepherd's pie, rich and hearty, is a must-try. For dessert, the bread pudding, warm and comforting, is a perfect end to your meal. Their beer selection, featuring local and international brews, is sure to please any beer lover, ensuring Nolan's Pub remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
9. The Kitchen & Bar at Safety Harbor Resort
The Kitchen & Bar at Safety Harbor Resort - 105 N Bayshore Dr, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
The Kitchen & Bar at Safety Harbor Resort offers a fine dining experience with a menu that highlights fresh, local ingredients. The elegant setting and stunning views make it a perfect spot for a special occasion, earning it a spot among the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Why It’s Special:
The upscale ambiance and focus on high-quality, locally sourced ingredients make The Kitchen & Bar a top dining destination in Safety Harbor. The beautiful views of the bay enhance the dining experience, solidifying its place as one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Don’t Miss:
The seared scallops, perfectly cooked and served with a flavorful sauce, are a standout dish. The filet mignon, tender and juicy, is a highlight of the menu. For dessert, the chocolate lava cake, with its gooey center, is a decadent treat. Their seafood chowder, rich and creamy, is a perfect starter, ensuring The Kitchen & Bar remains one of the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
Conclusion
Safety Harbor, FL, is a haven for food lovers, offering a diverse range of dining options from casual eateries to fine dining establishments. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, Southern cuisine, or a great burger, the best restaurants in Safety Harbor have something to satisfy every palate. So, next time you’re in Safety Harbor, be sure to check out these top spots for an unforgettable culinary experience, and discover why they are considered the best restaurants in Safety Harbor.
